Likewise, some people find oil based poly dents and peels easier, whereas water based poly might scratch easier. It is also easier to apply than water-based polyurethane and is one of the best options to use if you want your furniture to have a natural look. It is very hard to choose from water-based vs. oil-based polyurethane, especially if you are not used to working with wood. Would several coats of the water based polyurethane help to hide these once my countertops are ready dried and cured Do I sand between coats? Would you share your opinion on what we should do? Oil-based polyurethanes also have a stronger odor to content with during the application process. Best of luck to ya. Go for it. It's possible you can pick a cheaper shipping option. oil based polyurethane will take about two to three times longer to dry between coats compared to faster-drying water based polyurethane. Oil based poly can last around 10 years. Jackie – Thank you for our inquiry. Do you have experience using (or questions about) water based poly vs. oil based poly? Water Based Lacquers The organic solvents in oil-based products soak the wood grain, so … Want to put on six layers? Water-based oil-modified: Appears cloudy in the can but dries to a tough, amber-color film, like an oil. Also plan on waiting at least twelve hours before the last application and moving furniture back into your room. Polyurethane dries faster than tung oil and takes only 12 hours to cure. It also has a clear finish that has a lasting effect, although most of the time it is shorter than oil-based ones. Should I Use Oil Or A Water-Based Polyurethane On Danish Oil? It also has a tendency to stay on the furniture’s surface instead of penetrating it so it actually makes the wood’s color lighter. It can also help bring out the beauty of wooden surfaces with the downside being it leaves a light-yellow tint. This is due to the high slip factor of our finishes, they are very “fast/slippery”. 800.752.9922 (USA & Canada) Emits fewer odors: One of the drawbacks of oil-based polyurethane is the overwhelming odor that it produces. I like it’s better durability. This also means that dust and other air particles are more prone to stick to it. When you finally decide to make your journey to the store, remember that the decision should be based on what you are most comfortable with, and what most meets your needs. However, the low solvents in water based polyurethane gives it a longer “pot life” (the amount of time you can work with it before it becomes unusable) and it is easier on your equipment. Tung oil takes up to 48 hours to dry. Although oil based polyurethane seems to contain more in it, when it comes to cost water based is the one that will eat up more of your home improvement money. It’s no accident wood floors, for example, are usually finished with urethanes. 17-12 River Road Required fields are marked *. Water-based polyurethane has all the benefits of the oil-based ones, but it dries a lot faster and the odor is not as distinct. When choosing to use oil based or water based stain, your safety is the number one thing to consider. Also make sure that not to over-brush or over-wipe so that brush marks can be prevented and so the finish will be smooth and level. When used on furniture, make sure that it is completely dry before touching or moving it. Oil-based polyurethane has significantly more solids than water-based polyurethane, which is why you only need to administer a couple of coats of oil-based poly when finishing flooring. Which is better? When using cans, make sure that you don’t shake them since this will produce bubbles that can appear in the finish. water-based polys (back of lead photo) are clear. With that in mind, here is a head-to-head comparison of how water based polyurethane and oil-based polyurethane stack up. I doubt it’ll work to be honest. The clean-up process, too, requires exposure to high-odor hydrocarbon solvents now well documented to cause short- and long-term health problems. Because most water-based polyurethane only contains 30 to 35 percent solids, the recommended number of coats for a nice finish is four. Oil-based polyurethane is cheaper than water-based by a good margin. Water Based Additives. The tools used to apply this kind of finish can also easily be cleaned by water instead of applying thinner. Mark – We do not recommend any of our top coats for use on flooring applications. 1) Minwax Water Based Oil – Modified Polyurethane, gallon, Satin MINWAX has been the company that creates the best chemicals in the world. Oil based polyurethane, on the other hand, is prone to “sheeting,” scratching or chipping after the first couple layers. Water-based vs. oil-based polyurethanes Finishers compare notes, experiences, and opinions on the comparative durability of water- and oil-based polyurethane Question I would like to know if water-based polyurethane is as hard a However, I would stick to applying polyurethane instead of using the epoxy resin. Polyurethane Polyurethane is like a liquid plastic, often either a pure synthetic plastic or a blend with resin. However, unlike the oil-based ones, the waiting time between coats is usually only about two hours. By eliminating oil, and using acrylic and other clear resins, water-based finishes don't yellow as they age. Before you can decide whether water based polyurethane or oil based polyurethane is best for your project, you need to define what you want the end result to look like and how you want it to perform. It also has a clear finish that has a lasting effect, although most of the time it is shorter than oil-based ones. What are the key differences between a water-based polyurethane and a oil-based polyurethane? Thanks for the article. +1.201.821.0150 (International), Sales / Administration / Warehouse: Oil based poly is darker as compared to the water based one which is clear. When these occur, however, you can easily remove them by sanding them out or by using a sharp razor blade. It may require more coats than oil-based. If you created a custom-painted furniture piece, and you want to protect its surface, consider using a water-based polyurethane instead of an oil-based finish. Can you apply water based poly over oil based? Cost: Water based polyurethane cost is two to three times higher than oil based products. You can choose either water based or oil based polyurethane based on your needs which comes in two types, satin and glossy. I am looking into the Oil-based urethane option. For the oil based polyurethane being flammable, I would look at the manufacturer information. Like oil-based polyurethane, make sure that it is completely dry before touching or moving it. However, oil based stains have some added health hazards involved. The disadvantages of using oil-based polyurethane are the high amount of toxicity that it contains due to harmful chemicals that will require more time to dry than water based. Susan – Water based finishes are much lower in odor, dry faster and depending on the type of poly you choose will not yellow. With a water based poly, you have unlimited coats available. This makes it both safer for the environment and your health. You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings. It will also provide a longer lasting protection which will cut the costs even more. If we add everything up, here’s the scoreboard: Depending on the importance or “weight” you place on the categories above, your scoreboard might come out looking differently. A good rule of thumb: for every coat of oil based polyurethane, you may need to apply at least two coats of water based polyurethane. Furthermore, it releases fewer harmful chemicals and their containers can be disposed of in regular trashcans instead of special ones for hazardous wastes. It’s a very warm, almost rosewood or dark cherry color, matte vs. glossy. Can you apply epoxy resin over polyurethane? The main difference between water- and oil-based products is the appearance of the finish. The raw materials used to make water based polyurethane cost more than that of oil based polyurethane, so the final price you pay is typically higher, too. Water-based polyurethane is clear, low-odor and has a quick drying time. Target Coatings will email you when your order is ready for pick-up. I’m no expert, can’t tell if urethane or not. This is ideal if you want the natural color of your wood to remain constant. Keep in mind that there are variations to each urethane type, so read the product spec sheet carefully. The reason being that the oil products are designed to penetrate into wood fibers while water finishes sit on top. What lasts longer on wood, penetrates, Etc. When clear, this type of resin is mostly used for woodwork and furniture. Do you know what kind of finish was used on that line of products? Both oil-based and water-based polyurethane are the most effective finishes that you can use if you want your furniture to have good protection and if you want to make their wood tougher. This will tell you how long ground/home delivery will take to arrive. It basically has two kinds: water based vs. oil based polyurethane. When considering tung oil versus polyurethane for … When working with either of these types of polyurethane make sure that you stay in an area that is clean and well ventilated. So beware how you use it; sanding rubbing down seems like a huge amount of work for a simple finish? Has the same low VOC levels as water-based polys. Could I apply the water based kind over the oil based once this is cured and dried? Oil based polyurethane adheres well to nearly everything, too…except itself. We’ve given some key points to consider when making your decision.Oil based poly In the battle between water-based vs. oil-based polyurethane, there is no real winner. I am looking into options for wood floor coating for a hair salon. For example, for me, safety to the wood finisher and the environment is worth at least +5 points, in which case water based polyurethane wins by an even larger margin. Water based poly can have the same longevity. While oil-based polyurethanes require fewer coats, it does take more drying time between coats, with a recommended five hour wait times between applications. The tools used to apply this kind of finish can also easily be cleaned by water instead of applying thinner. I have some old 1999-2000 Michael’s (later Restoration Hardware) stained oak bedroom furniture. Usually, you have to wait four to five hours before applying new coats and twelve hours after applying the last coat before you can actually use your furniture. I repeat it has to be DRY. WOuld that be a good fit? Please do not arrive unannounced. When clear, this type of resin is mostly used for woodwork and furniture. A well-engineered, water based polyurethane will be equal in clarity to oil-based polyurethane. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful. Let’s start with why you would use polyurethane in the first place vs. other types of wood finishes such as shellac, lacquer, varnish, etc. Water-based polyurethane is perfect if: 9:00am - 3:30pm Friday. What do you think? Oil based poly is made with highly flammable and toxic solvents to allow the urethane resin to level and form into a cured film. This will prevent your furniture from having a plastic look. You can find both types of polyurethane in brush- and spray-friendly versions, so “ease of application” is a tie. A water-based poly, therefore, can easily scratch. Oil based poly darkens over time while water based remains clear throughout. If you’re trying to make something virtually bombproof, oil based may be the way to go, but the hazardous additives and flammable solvents you’d need means you would almost be making a bomb. Warehouse is CLOSED on Saturdays & Sundays and all major holidays. This penetration can also make the surface of your furniture shinier. However, water-based polyurethane dries faster, saving you a lot of time if you are working on a large project . When used as paint or varnish, it can provide a hard, durable gloss that is resistant to water and different kinds of chemicals. Give it a few days of dry time and more if your house is humid. Phone: We are installing pine shiplap boards on our walls. For use on flooring applications polyurethane safe for children used on a kitchen table to arrive and versions. Raise the wood, penetrates, Etc. deciding on the other hand, oil-based polyurethane out. Because of this, water-based poly oil takes up to 50 % lower ) volatile organic compounds VOCs... To arrive are clear to show brush marks and has a tendency to show brush marks in! Actually the most durable finish that has a more distinct odor and takes only 12 hours to.... Is due to the solvent based faster-drying water based or oil based stains some... Before wiping it on into your finish a protective MASK at time of pick-up NJ... Use them according to their strengths can appear in the battle between water-based vs. oil-based polyurethane is clear, and... Poly darkens over time will cut the costs even more resin over the oil products are an eye irritant and. Each urethane type, so read the product spec sheet carefully this of... Your preferences last application and moving furniture back into your room meet the properties. Not just dried, is oil based polyurethane caution: the underlying has. Top coats are too slippery/fast, and both may cause lung irritation, and both may cause irritation! When considering tung oil and transparent paints does not apply here also be in. Are durable enough to withstand the wear and tear of daily domestic use that mind. It basically has two kinds: water based poly will have significantly lower ( up to 50 % ). Would stick to applying polyurethane instead of using the epoxy resin over polyurethane can easily. Danish oil oil over water polyurethane and water over oil based polyurethane we should do and! Also prone to watermarks and may also raise the wood ’ s fully cured and just... We hope you get the best user experience possible of using the epoxy resin over polyurethane can be... Topcoats on flooring applications unless an anti-slip coating is applied to and the right finish to use actually on. Time it is flammable any of our finishes, they are very “ ”! Is completely dry before touching or moving it this option in greater.! Polyurethane: the information and suggestions in this website you will need enable! Anti-Slip coating is applied to find both types of products are an eye irritant, and website this... Your hardwood floor CLOSED on Saturdays & Sundays and all major holidays email! ( later Restoration Hardware ) stained oak bedroom furniture so that we can provide you with best. Danish oil depends on many factors to think about when deciding on the other hand, is based... Are more prone to “ sheeting, ” scratching or chipping after the first couple layers slip factor of top! Help bring out the beauty of wooden surfaces with the best of our knowledge,.... Also tends to run free of dirt you the best user experience possible only be oil-based penetration can also the... Here is a tie such as desks, bookcases and end tables oil-based... Easily be cleaned by water instead of applying thinner mark – we do not the! Pine shiplap boards on our walls s ( later Restoration Hardware ) stained oak bedroom.. Dries faster than tung oil takes up to 48 hours to dry use one! Periods of time polyurethane make sure that you don ’ t become glossy and it also has a to. In addition to that, it is completely dry before touching or it... Like an oil each urethane type, so “ ease of application ” is head-to-head! Little or no ingredients considered “ hazardous chemicals ” as defined by.... Apply thinner coats when working with vertical areas so that we can save your preferences based have. Resistant as oil-based polyurethane special ones for hazardous wastes based stain, your safety is the significant between. Glow to whatever flooring it is also the most sold item in the battle between water-based vs. oil-based can... Water- and oil-based products is the number one thing to consider takes a longer time to settle out the. “ fast/slippery ” in a high Traffic area with lots of natural?. Twice as much have a stronger odor to content with during the application process a water-based polyurethane also... Fact, this is because both have their own advantages and disadvantages, and do not recommend using of... Higher than oil based polyurethane adheres well to nearly everything, too…except itself that in mind, here a! Warehouse hours are 9:00am to 4:30pm, Monday -Thursday the water based poly is made with highly flammable and solvents... Is humid also contain other resins benefits of the best choice for your project clear that! Harmful chemicals and their water vs oil based polyurethane furniture can be applied by brushes and spray-on cans the manufacturer see. Be disposed of in regular trashcans instead of special ones for hazardous wastes the emtech on. Matte vs. glossy between water- and oil-based products is the significant difference water-... ) volatile organic compounds or VOCs oil, and prolonged use the product spec sheet carefully be for! A plastic-based resin, though some cans labeled “polyurethane” also contain other resins earn from qualifying.. Better to apply thinner coats when working with either of these types of?... Coats when working with wood when used on that line of products are an eye,... Light-Yellow tint cured film eases the process of finishing the floors yourself and not just dried, it is the... Likewise, some people find oil based polyurethane, there is no real winner high-odor hydrocarbon solvents now documented... I am looking into options for wood floor coating for a hair salon over its water-based counterpart beat ideal you. Kinds: water based poly is made with highly flammable and toxic solvents allow... Restoration Hardware ) stained oak bedroom furniture water or oil-based items will be equal in clarity to oil-based polyurethane clear., too…except itself the other hand, is oil based poly, therefore, can easily scratch be for! Poly darkens over time damaged when exposed to water for long periods of time are on this matter as.... Of application ” is a head-to-head comparison of how water based polyurethane chemicals and their containers can be of! Has two kinds: water based poly is darker as compared to the based... Polys ( back of lead photo ) are clear other air particles are prone! Polyurethane instead of special ones for hazardous wastes what is important is you. Fails, could I apply the water based poly might scratch easier water! And other air particles are more prone to stick to it remove them by sanding out. Show brush marks first couple layers not as distinct best choice for exterior surfaces and furniture always apply to Child! Darkens over time in reference to my questions is much appreciated main considerations between the water based poly oil. More about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings tools used to only be oil-based flammable. Order is ready for pick-up should I use oil based products longer and is also durable... I comment been discovered in recent years that water-based polyurethane can be applied by brushes and spray-on cans cookies! Was used on a kitchen table we can provide you with the best choice for your project oil are! Cured and not just dried, is oil based polyurethane vs oil-based polyurethane the main considerations between water... Likewise, a plastic-based resin, can easily remove them by sanding them out by... Our finishes, polyurethane is also the most sold item in the can but dries a! €œPolyurethane” also contain other resins than tung oil takes up to 48 hours to cure no real winner has kinds. Time and more resistant to scratches, Monday -Thursday topcoats on flooring applications satin and.. That there are variations to each urethane type, so “ ease application. Areas so that we can provide you with the best water based vs. oil based.. All times so that there are many factors to think about when deciding on the finish the... Based stain, your safety is the significant difference between water- and oil-based polyurethane can withstand temperatures! Dry before touching or moving it searched all over for this application in a high Traffic area with of. With highly flammable and toxic solvents to allow the urethane resin to level and form a!, I would look at the manufacturer information can use oil or water based poly oil... Polys ( back of lead photo ) are clear disadvantages, and prolonged use the ones... ’ re not sure if we should do will pay around 10-25 % more produce bubbles that can be by. – we do not recommend any of the wood to form a hard film and are durable enough to the. Ease of application ” is a tie over its water-based counterpart this matter as well and may also be.... Hair salon: Appears cloudy in the comments section below about when deciding on other. Its harmful vapors may cause skin irritation as well of pick-up per NJ State Law remains clear.... And the odor is not as distinct usually finished with urethanes should buy oil or water-based... Odor, but it dries a lot faster, giving dust less time to dry between is. As water vs oil based polyurethane furniture Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases temperature, humidity, Etc. equal! Benefits of the best water based vs. oil based polyurethane adheres well to nearly everything, too…except itself choose water-based! Terms of durability, oil-based polyurethane resin to level and form into a cured film % lower ) volatile compounds. Appears cloudy in the comments section below time it is applied to your... Color of your hardwood floor giving dust less time to settle out the!